Early releaseResults marked Preliminary are real but not yet validated.More
All results derive from public genome data and the records deposited with them. Kinship and sex calls use about 8x coverage per genome, which separates parent-offspring pairs from unrelated pairs clearly and from full sibs only narrowly. Each finding is labelled by source: measured, read from the deposit, or published.
Kinship test
Each relationship stated in the records is tested against the genomes. Parent and offspring share one allele at every site: relatedness is near 0.25 and opposite-homozygous sites (IBS0) are nearly absent. Full sibs also show relatedness near 0.25 but retain IBS0 sites. The test passes only when every recorded parent-offspring pair is recovered as parent-offspring, and kinship results are interpreted only after it passes.
Result
Recorded relationships under test
from depositRelatedness against IBS0, every pair
Sex check
Birds have ZW sex chromosomes: females are ZW, males ZZ. A female genome carries Z at half the autosomal depth and carries W. A male genome carries Z at full depth and almost no W. Discordance between genome and record indicates a sample swap, a mislabelled tube or a record error, and each invalidates analyses that rely on the record.
Z and W coverage, every bird
measuredBirds where genome and record disagree
Errors in the deposited records
Errors identified in the deposited metadata before genotyping. Each finding is labelled by source: measured, read from the deposit, or published.
Colony roster, PRJNA1456614
37 birds as deposited in NCBI BioSample. The suffix on each name is the hatch site. The band column is shown exactly as deposited. A band marked not this bird does not carry the bird's own number.
Six large inversions
Two birds can differ by tens of megabases of inverted sequence. Without inversion genotypes, principal component analysis resolves karyotype classes that are indistinguishable from population structure. Each bird is karyotyped first, and kinship is computed with and without the inversion chromosomes.
Inverted spans, drawn to scale
publishedBreakpoints and frequencies
Zebrafish: NHGRI-1 strain check
Every NHGRI-1 fish descends from one founding pair whose genomes were sequenced (LaFave et al. 2014, PRJNA246102). A fish sold as NHGRI-1 should therefore carry almost no allele that neither founder carries. Five fish sold as NHGRI-1 (Sanger, 2016, PRJEB20043; a Japanese laboratory, 2022, PRJNA1110785) are tested against the two founders, with four AB and TU fish from the same two studies as negatives.
Fruit fly: families and DGRP lines
Two tests on public Drosophila melanogaster genomes. Four wild-caught families, each a mother, a father and five sons (Wang et al. 2023, PRJEB51956), test recorded parentage and sex. Fourteen inbred DGRP lines resequenced by two other laboratories (PRJEB76922, PRJNA681089) are matched against the DGRP Freeze 2 genotypes to test line identity; a non-DGRP stock (Virginizer) is the negative.
Misassigned reference materials across biology
Policy
survey, unverifiedMethods, data and versions
Steps, in order
Data used
Reference
bTaeGut7 maternal haplotype, RefSeq GCF_048771995.1: 39 autosomes, Z and W, 1.14 Gb. Chromosomes are named by accession, with roles from the assembly report.
Sources of error
- Females are ZW, so Z is hemizygous. Z and W are excluded from kinship and used for sex.
- Zebra finches carry a germline-restricted chromosome, present in germline and absent from blood, so tissue changes the effective genome.
- Byte prefixes of the two read files hold different read counts. Pairs are trimmed to the shorter file, and a bird fails if one file ends far earlier than the other.
- Both studies contain recorded families, so population structure is estimated only after relatives are pruned.